
A Los Angeles County Medical Examiner’s report says the teenager who fell to his death at a Los Angeles public high school threw the first punch in the brawl that preceded his fatal jump, turning a viral bullying narrative on its head.
Story Snapshot
- The medical examiner ruled Xavier Nungaray-Martinez’s death a suicide, finding he “intentionally” jumped from a fourth-floor balcony at Benjamin Franklin High School.
- The report states Xavier punched a male classmate first, then tried to forcibly kiss a female student before the other boy punched him back.
- The Los Angeles Police Department says detectives have found no evidence tying bullying claims to the death, though the case remains open.
- Xavier’s parents reject the findings, have filed damage claims against the Los Angeles Unified School District, and plan a lawsuit alleging years of unaddressed bullying.
Medical Examiner’s Report Flips the Script
The medical examiner’s report, released November 17, found that Xavier died by suicide after intentionally jumping from a fourth-floor balcony. The report also states that moments before his death, Xavier punched a male student, who then punched him back. That timeline contradicts the version that spread online within hours of the September 30 incident.
The Los Angeles Times reported the full sequence laid out in the medical examiner’s file. Xavier allegedly threw the first punch, then tried to forcibly kiss a female student, who pushed him away. Only after that did the previously punched male student strike him. If accurate, that account reshapes who instigated the confrontation that preceded the fall.
Video from the classroom and hallway, described in earlier reporting, showed Xavier being hit, running out of the room, and going over the railing while another student appeared to follow him. That footage fueled the original bullying narrative before investigators released their own account of who struck first.
Police Say Bullying Link Remains Unproven
The Los Angeles Police Department has said plainly that its detectives have not found evidence connecting bullying allegations to Xavier’s death. The department’s statement was blunt: “At this preliminary stage of the investigation, detectives have not identified evidence establishing a connection between allegations of bullying and the student’s death”. That is a notable check on a narrative that spread fast on social media and shaped public opinion before investigators finished their work.
Still, the department’s statement was preliminary, not final. Police have released almost no other details about the ongoing investigation, even as the case remains open. That silence leaves room for both sides to claim the full picture has not yet come out, and it puts pressure on the district to explain what it knew about Xavier and his classmates before the fight ever happened.
Family Rejects Findings, Presses Lawsuit Against School District
Xavier’s mother has flatly rejected the suicide ruling. “This was not a suicide,” she said, adding that her son had been thinking about schoolwork, his responsibilities, and what he wanted to accomplish. The family’s attorneys describe video showing Xavier repeatedly punched on the classroom floor while a substitute teacher yelled for the fight to stop, then say he was pursued after fleeing the room.
The parents have filed damage claims against the Los Angeles Unified School District, alleging the district failed to protect Xavier despite years of bullying and prior warnings to administrators. An attorney for Xavier’s mother said he had been regularly targeted and beaten by a group of students during his sophomore year. Those claims are a formal first step toward a lawsuit against the taxpayer-funded district.
This case cuts to a question conservative parents have asked for years: why do massive school bureaucracies like LAUSD struggle to protect kids from known threats, yet move quickly to settle lawsuits after tragedy strikes? Courts across the country have repeatedly found it hard to pin legal blame for a suicide on a school, even when bullying is alleged, because proving direct cause is a steep legal bar. That reality does not erase the district’s responsibility to answer basic questions about supervision and prior warnings.
What Comes Next for Franklin High
Attendance at Franklin High reportedly plunged after the death, as rumors, hoax threats, and viral video shook the campus community. Parents deserve a full accounting from both the medical examiner and the school district, not dueling press statements. Until LAUSD releases disciplinary records, prior bullying complaints, and full video evidence, families on all sides will keep fighting over a story that official investigators say is far from settled.
Sources:
editions.geo.hosted.abcotvs.com, nypost.com, latimes.com, dailybreeze.com, cbsnews.com













