Mother’s Lie Triggers Unneeded Surgery

surgeons performing an operation
Photo: Shakirov Albert / Shutterstock

Deputies say a mother’s false claims pushed doctors into an invasive surgery for a healthy toddler.

Story Highlights

  • Sheriff’s office alleges a mother gave false medical histories that led to a gastrostomy tube surgery.
  • Reports say the two-year-old had about 175 medical visits in two years before the procedure.
  • A pediatric surgeon reportedly said he would not have done the surgery if given accurate facts.
  • Court records show a felony charge of child neglect causing serious bodily injury; the mother pleaded not guilty.

Deputies Outline Alleged Fabrication And Resulting Surgery

Monongalia County deputies in West Virginia said a 29-year-old mother, Emilee Guzman, misled doctors about her two-year-old’s eating and fear of food, which guided care toward a feeding-tube surgery on October 1, 2026. Officials said the history described a child who could not or would not eat, consistent with an avoidant or restrictive food intake problem. Investigators stated that this account helped drive the choice to place a gastrostomy tube, a procedure they now call medically unnecessary based on later findings.

Reports state the child had roughly 175 medical visits over two years, a pattern deputies reviewed while building the case. That contact spanned routine and specialist care and set the stage for high-risk treatment when doctors believed the child could not take food by mouth. Authorities said the bulk of decisions relied on caregiver reports that the child would not eat, which, if untrue or incomplete, would distort clinical judgment and increase harm to the child from avoidable interventions.

Investigation Cites Interview And Surgeon’s Counterfactual

Media accounts of the investigative file say Guzman admitted in an October 13, 2026 interview that she withheld details about what the child was actually eating, reportedly out of fear of a Child Protective Services referral. That alleged admission fits the timeline between the tube placement and the fast-moving review of records after the surgery. Deputies further cited the pediatric surgeon’s later statement that he would have pursued less invasive options if accurate intake information had been available.

Deputies also referenced a review by a child-abuse pediatrician at WVU Medicine Children’s Hospital who diagnosed medical child abuse, sometimes called Munchausen syndrome by proxy in news reports. That professional assessment, combined with the surgery and heavy use of medical services, shaped the charge. The sheriff’s office said inaccurate caregiver accounts about the child’s nutrition and symptoms led to harm through an invasive procedure that should not have occurred with full and accurate information.

Charges, Due Process, And Safeguarding Concerns

Monongalia County Magistrate Court records show a felony count of child neglect resulting in serious bodily injury. Reports say Guzman pleaded not guilty. That filing moves the case from clinical suspicion to a formal legal process, where evidence will be tested in court. Officials emphasized the alleged deception to clinicians and the direct link to the October surgery as key to the neglect charge and the claim of serious harm to the child from the medical intervention.

This case highlights a hard reality that parents, doctors, and law enforcement all face. Medical child abuse is rare, but it can cause serious harm when caregiver stories drive risky treatment. Guidance from child-safeguarding groups describes this problem as behavior that convinces professionals a child is sicker than they are, leading to tests, drugs, or surgeries that the child does not need. The goal in these cases is simple: protect the child fast and base every step on verified facts.

Sources:

nypost.com, lawandcrime.com, usmagazine.com, the-independent.com